Decisions

Well my job at the bridal gallery will come to an end this Saturday. So for about the last month I've been very stressed out about where I'll be working. Well yesterday I got offered two jobs both starting Monday!! My problem is, I have no idea which one to take. They are both jobs I've never done before, and I don't know very much about either one. Here is what I do know:
Job #1
Front Desk Clerk at Candlewood Inn and Suites.
-Pay is the same as I make now
-I would work 6a.m. to 2p.m. Monday-Wednesday and 2p.m to 10p.m Thursday and Friday.
-It's a pretty slow job where I'd be able to read and play online, just as long as I'm at the desk.
-Located close to home

Job#2
Graphics Person at Camden Library Group
-Pay is 50 cents more than what I make now and for the next several weeks overtime is mandatory.
-I'd go at 7 and stay until 4:30 or 5 on weekdays and some Saturdays are also required.
-It's a job with no downtime, I'd be working on making book covers more clear and data entry.
-Located in North Topeka
-It's through a temp agency but it's supposed to be a temp to hire position, but at the same time it's still through a temp agency

So basically two jobs that are completely opposite each other. I have to make a decision today and here is where I stand.
I wouldn't mind more pay, but I don't know how I feel about "mandatory" overtime.
Driving out there would use a lot of gas, so maybe all the overtime would just go to that anyway.
I dread the thought of temp work again.
But I don't like having nothing to do at work.
I don't want to work evenings, but I also don't want to work Saturdays.

Hmmm, am I just too picky?
Don't know what to do...